Weekly Progress – January 30th

Importance of Advisors/Mentors

As a first time entrepreneur its pertinent to have the right advice and people around you to ensure success.  I have always known that but I truly realized that over the last couple weeks. Until recently, I always thought of advisors as people that provide a “How To” guide.   They happen to do that, but its not their purpose.   Their most important role is of a “catalyzer.”  They help you take an idea and make it a reality.  Advisors push you to critically think.  Their advise eliminates some of the road bumps along the path of launching a business.  Advisors help you SHIP – turning of the creative in you for just a bit and actually make the idea as it stands a reality.

Ship

Ankeet and I finally reached a consensus - NO MORE CHANGES. While we expect to discuss little changes, our core business model and strategy will remain as is.  We have spent a year and half brainstorming, researching and formulating ideas, now its time to make it a reality.  We decide to agree and checked off on this important milestone after watching a video of Seth Godin sent to us by one of our advisors.

Watch it, its good! – http://bit.ly/4AyrM

Other Key Victories/Losses this week

The marketing strategy has taken concrete form and we began implementing it this week.  Our plan may run into scalability issues as we expand to more schools.  But, we will go with what we have.

Challenges as a student Entrepreneur

At DePaul, our weekend start on Thursdays since we do not have Friday classes.  Engines turn off and its time to unwind starting Thursday night.   Sometimes its difficult to go from the college student mode to entrepreneur – going out with friends is a lot more enjoyable than writing a bplan.  It best to balance, go out but at the same time don’t forget your to do list for your business.  Creating a milestone sheet  well ahead of time and having someone to keep you accountable has helped me key in the right stroke.

Weekly Progress – Jan 18th, 2010

Business Modeling
This week we hashed out the business model for Redeal.me.  We realized that a pure advertisement model is unsustainable; therefore, we are adopting the freemium model – provide some services at no charge while others will cost something.  We are still deciding on the specifics of the model.
The best model maximizes revenue without hindering the acquisition of new users.   While predicting the “most efficient” model is important, it will most likely be wrong.  Without any real user data, it is like shooting darts in the dark.  The final numbers may be wrong, but predicting requires one to research and understand the various possible options.  Building this understanding is probably the most valuable part of this entire process.
Outsourcing and its challenges
We hired a web designer and paid him on a per project basis.  Amazed by his dedication and creativity, we decided to hire him on a monthly basis.  Everything was fine for a week of so, until he stopped responding to emails and missed a couple of meetings.  We waited for a week or so and had no responses.  It was definitely a noticeable setback since we depended on him for all our design work (web and marketing).
Lesson Learned – Don’t but all your eggs in one basket.  From here onwards, we will probably work with a minimum of two designers.  If one balks, the other one can pick up the slack.  Another way to avoid such a situation would be to hire a credible firm rather than a person to do the job.  It will cost more, but probably a wise investment if the job is critical to move forward….

How to Monetize on Facebook

Well, to have solved this puzzle you must be the founder of Zynga. The company has scores of games; most notable is Farmville and Mafia wars. Zynga has ranked number one in Facebook games (Fun applications) with millions of users. Proof

The question is how you become the next Zynga, well if not Zynga, maybe ‘application 1000’ that boasts a million users. Most applications on Facebook are crap. Yes, I repeat – Crap. They offer the user no utility or fun. Zynga has perfected the art of a fun application, and if you have a better idea – they will copy and crush you with a bigger marketing budget. Not a bad strategy, it worked well for Microsoft.

The question still remains to how to monetize on Facebook. With CPM rates being a paltry $0.23  - is developing and investing in a Facebook application futile? Offering the user utility that is currently unavailable is the fastest way to grow and yes – monetize.  Keeping the user engaged is important, but what’s most important to new users is a unique tool (application) for their daily tasks and that is relevant to their lives.

I will leave with this message – develop a Facebook application that is scalable, useful and not spam. I am not sure if users have hit ‘Crap’ Facebook application fatigue yet, but application growth indicates that useless applications remain unsuccessful.

BPlan Competition – A little more success

With a business idea and monetization strategy in mind, we began writing a business plan for the DePaul competition.  Humbler and with a little bit of experience, we made it to the final round of the competition.

By the time we submitted our business plan, we had a strong idea but the monetization strategy still lacked simplicity.  It was convoluted and did not make sense.  However, we did not realize that until our business idea was criticized on stage by the judges during the final round presentation. “Criticize” may not be the right word, since it has a negative connotation.  So, let me define it as harsh but much needed advice.  The monetization strategy was not sound.  Here is an abridged version of the problems our monetization idea (virtual currency) created:-

-          Users have to enter in Credit Card information on FB

-          Service has a charge

-          Buyers and Sellers are hidden from each other

-          Have to verify completion of transaction (transfer of book for seller to buyer)

-          Users can easily cheat the system and avoid the fee

-          Implementing a virtual currency system cost a lot of mula!

Charging a flat fee (ex:$1 for each book listed) or a freemium model (ex: 5 free listings and each additional listing costs a $1) are both feasible.  It is actually something we may revisit.  However, charging a fee based on the completion of the transaction is definitely unrealistic.  Andrew Chen probably explains the Freemium model better than anyone else.  Here is one of his blog posts – http://bit.ly/2DuhW.

(Written in 01/10, hence the past tense)

Virtual Cash

As we explored monetization strategies, virtual currencies was emerging as the next cash cow online and especially on social networking websites.  Companies such as Zynga, developer of Farmville and Mafia Wars, successfully monetized on their games using virtual currency.  You can read more about virtual currency and it success on http://bit.ly/alIcw.

On most games players receive an in-game benefit for spending virtual currency.  The in-game benefit range from giving you access to new weapons to increasing the speed of a house being built within the game.  As mentioned in the article, players earn virtual money by completing offers and surveys, making mobile payments and direct payments via credit card or Paypal.

On our website, users would get virtual currency by making direct payments via a credit card or a Paypal account.  The survey route seemed too spammy and the mobile payments were too expensive to implement.   Unlike other websites, rather than spending virtual currency for an in-game benefits, users would buy and sell books.  The idea sounded great and we went with it.

(Written in 01/10, hence the past tense)

Classtexts4less.com –> Rebook.me –> Redeal.me (Our evolution in terms of name

After the summer of 2008, we began brainstorming for new ideas.  Our focus remained on using technology to solve everyday problems faced by students and educators.  We wanted to stick to this market since we understood it very well as students ourselves.

It was time for school again, and going through the painful process of buying books.  The bookstore was unaffordable, so I ordered most of my books from online marketplaces.  But, it was always a hassle ordering online since the delivery date was at least 14 days after the order date.  We talked to other students, and they faced the same dilemma.

After much brainstorming, we decided to start a local book exchange website.  Initially we were very excited, but after a few hours of research; tons of such websites already existed.   But, surprisingly, not many people used these websites.  After much debate and research, we realized that the websites did not focus in on specific geographic area or school.  And adding to that, most of the websites had poor user interface (UI).   Still exploring the idea, we spoke to friends that could possibly help us.  A good friend of mine recommended developing a Facebook Application.  Most students were on Facebook, and if properly marketed, the application can go viral.

With that in mind, we built our strategy around developing a Facebook Application.  While we had found a better medium, the monetization strategy was still is in question.  We really had no home run strategy.  Most of our ideas of money making ideas already existed (affiliate programs, banner ads etc).  For the application to hit its potential, we really need to find a new type of “secret sauce.”

(Written in 01/10, hence the past tense)

A Humbling Experience

The competition opened my eyes to the world of business.  It isn’t easy to succesfully launch and grow a business.  A vision is important, but a diligent approach is most valued.  After the competition, I was humbled and learned to listen; probably the two most important characteristics for any entrepreneur.

We took the advice given by the judges and reevaluated our business.  Unable to fill the holes and answer the key questions, we decided to move onto another idea.

(Written in 01/10, hence the past tense)

My First Days as an Entrepreneur and as a DePaul Student

As a freshman at DePaul, I just wanted to get out in the real world and start something of my own.  I had the naïve perception that every and any business would be successful.  My brother, Ankeet and I would always talk about starting ventures.  We found an opportunity to test our idea at the DePaul Business Plan Competition 2007.  We made it through the preliminary – submit your exec. summary round.  With a lot of excitement, we started to right our business plan.

The 20 to 30 page document did not seem to be an insurmountable challenge.  After all, the money, fame and glory was all going to roll in as soon as we typed our vision onto paper.  (All that did not exactly pan out as we expected J)

Writing the plan proved to be tougher than imagined, especially the marketing and competitive advantage parts of the business.  We patched up a document of 20 pages or so 5 minutes before the deadline and submitted it. Excited to finish, we waited for the feedback from the judges.

When we received our responses, the judges crushed our idea, and rightfully so.  They pointed to the (many) holes in business plan.  Starting from the executive summary to the exit strategy, our business plan was as good as trash.  We even had typos – a big no no for any formal document!

(Written in 01/10, hence the past tense)

Welcome to the EntrepreNerdBlog

This Blog is designed for budding Entrepreneurs.

The blog is an intellectual forum for Entrepreneurs to share and test their ideas. We will feature important White papers from various universities and knowledge houses. The final goal is to get an weekly post from a true Entrepreneur – Been there, done that – sort of person.

Rethink | Rebel | Redo = Innovation Economics